Nationwide emerges as the top car insurance company of 2024, while USAA and Travelers also receive a 5-star rating in our comprehensive evaluation.

In order to identify the top car insurance companies, our team of experts thoroughly evaluated rates for nine different driver profiles, alongside important metrics including customer complaint ratio, collision repair score, and the range of coverage options and features offered by each insurer.

In the year 2024, a list of the top car insurance companies has been compiled.
The top car insurance provider across the nation is Nationwide.

USAA is widely recognized as the top provider of car insurance for military personnel.
For individuals who have recently purchased a new vehicle, Travelers offers exceptional car insurance coverage.
Erie is widely regarded as the top choice for car insurance when it comes to handling claims.
Geico offers exceptional car insurance options specifically tailored for individuals with a less-than-ideal credit history.
When it comes to finding the most suitable car insurance for individuals with a DUI, Progressive stands out as the top choice.

Which car insurance company is considered the best?

Based on our comprehensive assessment of auto insurance rates, coverage options, and consumer complaints, Nationwide, Travelers, and USAA emerge as the top-notch auto insurance companies. These insurers not only receive a 5-star rating in our analysis but also secure leading positions in our rankings for the most affordable car insurance, optimal car insurance for teenagers, and excellent car insurance for senior citizens.

When searching for a highly rated auto insurance provider, it is crucial to be aware that USAA car insurance exclusively caters to military members, veterans, and their eligible family members.

Auto-Owners and USAA are recognized as the top providers of liability car insurance.

Auto-Owners and USAA are renowned for offering the most affordable liability-only car insurance options.

While Auto-Owners may not be included in our list of top-rated car insurance companies for this year, it does offer the most affordable liability-online coverage, with an average annual rate of $404. However, it is worth noting that USAA follows closely behind with an average rate of $466 per year.

Auto-Owners, Nationwide, and Travelers are among the top car insurance options recommended for seniors.

For drivers who are 65 years old or above, Nationwide and USAA are highly recommended car insurance companies across the nation. Both insurers have received a 5-star rating in our comprehensive evaluation of the best car insurance options specifically tailored for seniors.

Senior drivers can take advantage of Nationwide’s affordable rates, averaging at $1,402 per year or approximately $117 per month.

When it comes to finding the ideal car insurance for teenagers, Nationwide and Erie are the top choices.

Nationwide and Erie are the top-rated car insurance companies for teenagers, according to our analysis. Both companies have received a 5-star rating specifically for this age group, considering factors such as rates, customer complaints, collision claim experience, and beneficial features for families with young drivers. These features include accident forgiveness and a diminishing deductible.

For parents seeking the most comprehensive coverage at an affordable price, Nationwide is a viable option, with an average annual rate of $2,819, equivalent to a mere $235 per year.

For teenagers in search of their own car insurance coverage, Erie is worth considering. With an average annual rate of $2,921, or $243 per month, it offers the lowest rates available.

Erie stands out as the top choice for car insurance when it comes to claims.

After experiencing an accident, the last thing on your mind should be the concern of whether your insurance company will effectively manage your claim. Based on the latest evaluation from the CRASH Network Insurer’s Report Card, Erie has been identified as the top insurer with the most reliable claims process.

By surveying more than 1,000 collision professionals, the CRASH Network gathers valuable insights into the various approaches taken by different car insurance companies when it comes to managing claims. These insurers are evaluated and assigned a grade ranging from A+ to F, which reflects their performance across critical aspects like the claims handling procedure, repair quality, payment process, and overall customer satisfaction.

Out of all the top auto insurance companies, Erie emerged as the frontrunner with the highest CRASH Network score. It is also worth mentioning that Erie achieved the second-highest score in the latest J.D. Power U.S. Auto Claims Satisfaction Study.

Discovering the ideal car insurance company that suits your needs can be quite a task.
If you’re in the market for the top car insurance provider, following these steps can be beneficial in your search.

Assess and establish your fundamental requirements for coverage.

Familiarize yourself with the car insurance regulations in your state. The majority of states mandate that drivers have at least a minimum amount of liability insurance, while others go a step further and require additional coverage like uninsured motorist insurance or personal injury protection (PIP).
In the event that you have obtained a loan for your vehicle or are leasing it, your lender or lessor will probably mandate that you maintain comprehensive auto insurance coverage, encompassing both collision and comprehensive policies. Additionally, they may insist on you having gap insurance.
Take into account the additional coverage and features that you desire or require.

Certain insurance providers offer additional benefits such as vanishing deductibles, new car replacement coverage, and rideshare coverage, distinguishing themselves from those who do not provide these options.
After a DUI, many individuals find themselves in need of SR-22 filing, although not all auto insurance companies provide this service.
Assess the advantages and cost reductions.

Would you be interested in utilizing a mobile application to effectively handle your car insurance policy and submit claims?

If you choose to obtain your car insurance policy from the same insurer that provides your home and/or renters insurance, you may be eligible for a bundling discount.
Seek out reviews of car insurance companies.

Explore online reviews from industry professionals to make an informed decision about car insurance.
Gather information about car insurance by consulting with friends, family, or colleagues regarding their personal experiences in this area.
Take the time to compare different quotes for car insurance.

To ensure you make an informed decision, it is recommended that you obtain a minimum of three car insurance quotes for identical coverage, allowing you to compare and select the most suitable option for your needs.

It is important to remember that the most affordable car insurance may not necessarily be the most optimal choice.

Before making a decision, it is important to take into account the benefits, features, as well as professional and customer reviews.

Various factors contribute to the overall cost of car insurance.
In order to obtain the most favorable rates for auto insurance, it is beneficial to have a comprehensive understanding of the criteria that insurance companies consider when determining your premium. Below are several factors that will play a role in determining the cost of your auto insurance.

Your policy can encompass various types of car insurance, which may also include optional coverages.
The choice of coverage limits is up to you.
When applicable, you have the option to select the amount of your auto insurance deductible.


  • Types of car insurance you include in your policy, including optional coverages.
  • Coverage limits you choose.
  • Auto insurance deductible amount you choose, when applicable.
  • Your age.
  • Your gender (except in California, Hawaii, Massachusetts, Michigan, North Carolina and Pennsylvania).
  • Your location.
  • Your car insurance claims history.
  • Your car insurance history.
  • Your credit-based insurance score (except in California, Hawaii, Massachusetts and Michigan).
  • Your vehicle.

Your choice of vehicle has a direct influence on the cost of your car insurance. Our highest-rated insurers have provided us with the average annual rates for various popular vehicle makes and models.